Indianapolis Colts bars in New York City 2025: Find a Colts bar near you
Where to watch the Indianapolis Colts in New York City. Keats Bar has hosted Colts fans since 2009 with full game sound.
If you’re a Colts fan in New York City, there’s a long-running blue-and-white home base that delivers full game audio, cold beer, and a loyal crowd. Whether you’re a local or visiting for the weekend, you’ll find friendly regulars, classic pub fare, and a gameday buzz that turns Midtown East into Indy East.
You can find bars for your favorite NFL and college football teams on the 2nd Home Map, the most comprehensive team bar map anywhere on the internet. Know a bar that should be added to the map? Tell us about it here!
Keats Bar
Address: 842 Second Ave New York, NY 10017
Phone: (212) 682-5490
Connect: Website | Facebook | Instagram
Home to Colts fans since 2009, Keats is a classic Midtown East pub that turns into a sea of blue on gamedays—complete with full audio and a lively crowd. The Irsay family has been known to drop by when the team is in town.
Join your local fan club here: NYC Colts @ Keats
How to find bars for your favorite NFL or college football teams
Looking for a place to cheer on your favorite NFL or college football team with fellow fans? 2nd Home Sports makes it easy. Use the interactive 2nd Home Sports Map to explore verified team bars across the U.S., from neighborhood hangouts to game-day hotspots. Filter by team, browse city by city, and open detailed bar profiles with addresses, contact info, and notes about the fan scene so you know exactly where to go on Saturdays and Sundays.
Have a go-to spot that belongs on the map? You can help grow the community by submitting it through the Nominate a Bar page. Share the bar’s name, location, and any social links or club details—your tip could help hundreds of fans find their new home base on game day.
Every listing on 2nd Home Sports goes through a strict verification process to keep the map accurate and trustworthy. The team relies on human review, checks for photo and video evidence from real game days, and runs routine audits to confirm that bars still host specific fanbases each season. When something changes—like a bar switching teams, moving, or closing—those updates are reflected quickly so fans aren’t left guessing.
Whether you’re traveling for an away game or settling in for a local watch party, 2nd Home Sports gives you a reliable, up-to-date guide for finding your crowd. Start planning your next game day with the 2nd Home Sports Map, and keep the network strong by pitching your favorite spots via the Nominate a Bar form.